Renting a car in New Jersey might sound like the easy option, but the hidden costs and strict terms often make it more trouble than it’s worth. What looks like freedom on the surface quickly turns into a list of restrictions, fees, and insurance complications.
Jump To Section
From high daily rates to added charges for fuel, mileage, and late returns, renters are often caught off guard. Many drivers also face insurance confusion, safety concerns, and stress from driving unfamiliar vehicles, especially in busy cities like Newark or Jersey City.
Before you sign the rental agreement, it’s worth understanding the drawbacks. These top 10 points break down what you need to watch out for, so you can make a smarter travel decision in New Jersey.
What Are The Top 10 Reasons Not To Rent A Car
The top ten reasons not to rent a car include high rental costs, hidden fees, complex insurance terms, unfamiliar vehicles, strict documentation requirements, environmental concerns, surprise post-rental charges, parking challenges, potential safety issues, and limited travel flexibility. Whether you’re visiting for a week or staying longer, these challenges can easily turn a simple trip into a frustrating experience.
Below are the ten reasons not to rent a car:
1. High Rental Costs
Renting a car in New Jersey quickly becomes expensive, especially during weekends, holidays, or tourist seasons. Base rates might look fair at first, but once you add fuel, tolls, daily insurance, and taxes, the cost usually surpasses what you’d spend on ride-hailing apps or public transit. If you’re not using the car all day, that extra cost delivers very little value.
2. Hidden Fees and Charges
Rental companies often advertise low rates but bury extra charges in the fine print. You might get billed for GPS devices, car seats, additional drivers, cleaning fees, or late returns, and these fees are rarely disclosed clearly during booking. Even fuel refill charges can be much higher than local pump prices, adding to your final bill without warning.
3. Complex Insurance Requirements
Understanding what insurance actually covers is one of the most confusing parts of renting a car. Your own car insurance or credit card might offer some protection, but it’s not always enough. If you decline the rental company’s insurance and damage occurs, you risk paying out of pocket for repairs, liability, or towing, especially if exclusions apply.
4. Unfamiliar Vehicle Handling
Every car drives differently, and rental cars aren’t always the easiest to adjust to. Whether it’s a larger vehicle than you’re used to, different controls, or new technology, driving unfamiliar cars increases stress and the likelihood of accidents. This is especially challenging in high-traffic New Jersey cities like Newark, where quick reactions and tight spaces are the norm.
5. Strict Documentation and ID Policies
You’ll need a valid driver’s license, a credit card in your name, and sometimes a second ID or proof of address to complete a rental. Some companies also run credit checks or require large security deposits. If you forget any documents or if there’s an issue with your card, you could be denied the rental on the spot, with no refund for prepaid bookings.
6. Environmental Impact of More Vehicles
Renting adds another car to the road, and in areas like Jersey City, Hoboken, or Princeton, that contributes to congestion, emissions, and urban crowding. Local governments are pushing toward car-free transport zones and encouraging public transit or cycling. Choosing a rental in these areas might go against current efforts to reduce environmental pressure.
7. Unexpected Charges After Return
Some renters face charges days after they’ve returned the vehicle, for scratches, dents, extra cleaning, or fuel discrepancies. These disputes are difficult to fight, especially when you’re no longer near the rental office. Without photos or written confirmation at drop-off, you’re at the mercy of the company’s internal policies and inspections.
8. Parking and Navigation Difficulties
Parking in cities like Trenton or Atlantic City is both expensive and limited. Many streets have time-restricted meters or require residential permits, leading to fines if you park in the wrong spot. Without local knowledge, you also risk getting lost or taking inefficient routes, which increases fuel costs and wastes valuable travel time.
9. Safety Concerns with Vehicle Condition
Not all rental cars are in top shape. While major companies do regular maintenance, smaller or budget outfits might cut corners. Renters have reported issues like low tyre pressure, malfunctioning brakes, or dirty interiors. These problems affect your safety and comfort, especially if you’re travelling long distances across the state.
10. Limited Flexibility with Travel Plans
Rental agreements are strict. You’re usually tied to a return time, a fuel policy, and location-based rules. Want to extend the trip or return the car to a different location? That’s extra. Want to visit another state? Some companies restrict out-of-state travel altogether. These limitations make your trip less spontaneous and more stressful.
Is Renting a Car More Expensive Than Other Transportation Options?
Yes, renting a car in New Jersey is usually more expensive than using public transport, ride-hailing apps, or even bike-sharing services, especially for short or city-based trips. The base rental rate rarely reflects the total cost.
You’ll need to pay for insurance, fuel, tolls, parking, and taxes — all of which add up fast. In cities like Newark or Jersey City, daily parking alone can cost $20 to $40, while PATH trains, NJ Transit, or Uber cover the same distance at a fraction of the price.
If you’re only moving around urban centres or going between set locations, the car often sits unused, while the meter keeps running. Unless you’re covering long distances every day, renting a car offers poor value compared to other local options.
What Hidden Fees Should I Be Aware of When Renting a Car In New Jersey?
When renting cars in New Jersey, be aware of hidden fees that inflate the total cost far beyond the advertised rate. These charges appear during pickup or return, and most drivers don’t expect them.
Below are the hidden fees to be aware of when renting a car:
- Additional Driver Fee: Around $10–$15 per day if someone else drives.
- Underage Driver Fee: Renters under 25 pay up to $30 daily.
- Fuel Refill Charge: Returning without a full tank may cost $8–$10 per gallon.
- Toll Pass Charges: EZ-Pass device rental costs $3–$5 per day, plus tolls.
- Late Return Fee: Can be a full extra day’s rate for just a 30-minute delay.
- Cleaning Fee: Smoking or heavy dirt can result in $50–$150 charges.
- GPS and Child Seat Rental: GPS adds $10–$15 per day, child seats $10+.
These charges are rarely included in the quoted price. Unless you read the terms carefully, you risk paying 30–50% more than expected by the end of your trip.
How Can Insurance Complications Affect My Car Rental Experience?
Insurance complications affect my car rental experience by increasing the total cost, creating coverage confusion, delaying claims, exposing me to full liability, and limiting the use of credit card benefits. If you don’t fully understand the insurance for leased car before signing, a small accident or dent could cost you hundreds or even more out of pocket.
Below are the insurance complications that affect your car rental experience:
- You risk full liability: Without proper coverage, you may be held responsible for all damages, even if the accident wasn’t your fault.
- Rental company insurance is expensive: Optional insurance can cost $15–$40 per day in New Jersey.
- Personal insurance may not apply: Some policies exclude rentals, especially luxury cars or out-of-state use.
- Credit card coverage has limits: Many cards only cover collision, not liability, and require you to decline the rental company’s insurance.
- Claims are slow and complex: If damage occurs, you’ll deal with third-party insurers and may wait weeks for reimbursement.
- Surprise fees still apply: Even with insurance, you may pay for administrative fees, loss of use, or towing.
- Policy exclusions cause denial: If you break any rental rule or misreport damage, insurers may refuse to pay.
- Duplicate coverage adds cost: Some renters unknowingly pay for both personal and rental insurance.
- Not all vehicles are covered: Exotic cars, vans, or trucks may be excluded from standard policies.
- Emergency support is limited: If you have an accident after hours, resolving claims or repairs becomes harder.
What Are the Legal and Documentation Requirements for Renting a Car?
The legal and documentation requirements for renting a car in New Jersey include presenting a valid driver’s licence, a credit card in the renter’s name, and proof of age. Some companies also require secondary ID, insurance details, and even credit checks, depending on the rental terms.
Below are the common documentation and legal requirements for renting a car:
- Valid driver’s licence: You must present a state-issued or recognised international licence. Expired or provisional licences are not accepted.
- Minimum age: Most companies require you to be at least 21, but drivers under 25 often pay an underage fee of up to $30/day.
- Credit card in the renter’s name: This is used for holding a security deposit and paying for damages or incidentals. Debit cards are rarely accepted.
- Prepaid bookings still require documents: Paying online doesn’t waive ID requirements without documents, you won’t get the car.
